Strategy

Anesthesia Services Agreement: 10 Clauses to Check Before You Sign or Renew

By , Managing Director · Published

Anesthesia Services Agreement: 10 Clauses to Check Before You Sign or Renew

The short answer: the clauses that cost hospitals money are rarely the stipend itself. They are the ones that decide what happens when something changes: how the stipend is reconciled against collections, what counts as covered, what the hospital can see, who carries risk when coverage fails, and what each side can do when the agreement ends. This checklist uses language from public hospital agreements, RFP sample contracts and court filings. The sample is small (five public-entity documents and five contracts quoted in court opinions), so it shows what is possible, not what is standard. This is a finance-side guide, not legal advice; have counsel review any agreement.

The ten clauses

ClauseWhat public documents showWhat to check
1. ExclusivitySouth Broward (1997): the group provides “all Anesthesiologist Services at the Hospital on an exclusive basis,” and the district agrees not to grant privileges to other anesthesiologists or CRNAs. Salinas Valley (2023): “exclusive coverage for anesthesia services.”What the hospital gets in return for exclusivity, how it ends, and what happens to the other clinicians’ privileges.
2. Coverage scheduleKern (2016) attaches a table of hours by operating room and a 1:4 physician-to-CRNA ratio. South Broward requires 24 hours a day, seven days a week, with an anesthesiologist physically present.Hours, rooms, call, and whether coverage is in-house or on-call. MGMA notes that “24/7 coverage” alone is not enough.
3. Failure to coverNatividad’s sample lets the hospital “make alternative arrangements” without relieving the contractor of its obligations. One Indiana contract reimbursed half of locum costs in defined cases.Who pays for replacement coverage and what the hospital may withhold. We found no public anesthesia example of liquidated damages or payment offsets for missed coverage.
4. Stipend and reconciliationSalinas: $300,000 a month base plus a $400,000 yearly incentive pool. In Community Anesthesia & Pain Treatment v. St. Mary Medical Center, the parties had to complete an accounting reconciliation within 45 days after each quarter; if collections exceeded the $2.1 million guarantee, the group repaid accrued shortfall amounts within 15 days.Fixed or collections-based; any cap; how often it reconciles; the refund deadline; whether an incentive withhold applies. HSG Advisors favors a revenue guarantee and suggests withholding 5% to 10% of each eligible subsidy dollar.
5. Billing and dataNatividad’s template gives the hospital the sole right to bill (an optional variant), requires payer enrollment to begin within 10 business days of request, allows audit of “all records,” and sets 10-year retention. South Broward: the group bills “at its risk and expense.” NuHealth (2025): the group bills for professional services, with records kept six years and open to audit.Who bills, audit and records access, retention, and monthly data. We found no public example of a group handing over its payer contracts or rates, so ask for it.
6. Insurance and tail$1 million per claim and $3 million aggregate appears in South Broward, Natividad, Salinas and NuHealth. Natividad requires tail coverage on termination; South Broward lets the district buy it and bill the group if proof is missing.Limits, claims-made versus occurrence, tail obligations and who pays. See what changing groups costs.
7. Performance termsNatividad: first-case delays under 1%, anesthesia-related cancellations under 5%, turnaround under 30 minutes. Kern (2016): reduce cancellations 3% to 5% a year and lower a 15% rate to 5%. NuHealth tracks on-time starts, cancellations and complications.Measures that the group controls, with data both sides can see, and what follows from missing them.
8. Term, renewal and exitTerms of two to three years and notice from 30 to 180 days in the documents we read; see the renewal timeline. AANA’s checklist says a 90-day termination notice is common.Renewal mechanics, non-renewal notice, without-cause notice, cure period, and holdover terms.
9. Transition on exitNatividad requires care of current patients until treatment is complete or the patient is transferred, and bars interference with the hospital’s efforts to engage someone else. NuHealth requires assistance with the transition “regardless of the reason for termination,” with no day count.A fixed continued-coverage period, records and equipment return, and cooperation with the successor. We found no public anesthesia contract that fixed a number of days.
10. Restrictive covenantsAmerican Anesthesiology of Georgia v. Northside: a clause barring the hospital from hiring the group’s “Physician Extenders” during the term and for one year after was held reasonable and enforceable. In St. Joseph’s v. NAPA the agreement had a two-year non-solicit, and, according to a law-firm summary, the court let antitrust claims proceed.No-hire and non-solicit scope, duration, any buyout, and carve-outs if the hospital ends the agreement without cause.

Assignment and change of control

This matters whenever a private-equity or national group buys the one you contract with. South Broward treats a change of control as an assignment and lets the district terminate on 30 days’ notice. Natividad and NuHealth bar assignment without written consent, and Natividad allows termination after an unapproved “substantial change.” See our post on private equity in anesthesia.

Exclusivity, antitrust and the law around restrictive covenants

  • Exclusive contracts are not unlawful in themselves. In Jefferson Parish Hospital District No. 2 v. Hyde, 466 U.S. 2 (1984), the Supreme Court held the exclusive anesthesia contract at issue did not violate section 1 of the Sherman Act. The syllabus says anticompetitive consequences arise only if patients are forced to buy the contracting firm’s services because of the hospital’s market power.
  • The FTC’s noncompete rule is not in force. The Commission voted 3-1 on September 5, 2025 to dismiss its appeal and accept the court’s vacatur, and the rule was removed from the Code of Federal Regulations in February 2026. The Commission can still act case by case.
  • States differ widely. A September 2026 summary by Becker’s of a Tucker Arensberg guide counts 18 states that generally ban or void physician noncompetes. Florida has a narrow exception where one entity employs or contracts with every physician in a specialty in a county. Texas caps physician noncompetes at one year and five miles, with a buyout, and does not enforce them after an involuntary termination without good cause. Those rules govern clinician agreements; a hospital’s no-hire clause is a different instrument, as the Georgia decision shows.

Privileges when an exclusive contract ends

The governing body is responsible for services furnished under contract (42 CFR 482.12(e)), and bylaws must include criteria for granting privileges (482.22(c)(6)). Joint Commission standards require a fair hearing and appeal process for adverse decisions about privileges that may relate to quality of care. Courts have generally held that a loss caused by a business decision to enter or end an exclusive contract does not trigger hearing rights: the Tenth Circuit in Stears v. Sheridan County Memorial Hospital said privileges guarantee “the authority, not the wherewithal, to practice,” and the Illinois Supreme Court in Garibaldi v. Applebaum said the decision to enter an exclusive contract “cannot be deemed corrective action.” The contrary case is anesthesia-specific: in Volcjak v. Washington County Hospital Association (Md. Ct. Spec. App. 1999), bylaws gave members of closed departments hearing rights “unless the contract prohibits a procedural appeal,” and the court declined to let the hospital terminate privileges simply by entering an exclusive contract. Natividad’s template answers this with an express waiver of a “fair hearing” on termination. Check your bylaws against the agreement.

What to compare against, and who is writing

  • Coronis Health (article by counsel to anesthesia groups): the coverage grid should show the exact days and times anesthesia is required, including call; audit rights over the group’s books are common; and if net collections exceed the hospital’s payments the group must refund the difference.
  • Baker Donelson (group-side advice on physician group agreements, not anesthesia-specific): initial terms are “usually between three to 10 years” with “one to two years” notice for without-cause termination, and base payments should be reconciled to actual performance monthly or quarterly. That is longer than the public anesthesia documents we read.
  • Enhance Healthcare: in an uncapped revenue guarantee, the hospital makes up every uncollected dollar.
  • AANA publishes a model agreement and checklist written from the CRNA side.

We found no survey of contract length or without-cause notice. An Anesthesia Business Consultants note in 2009 said two- and three-year hospital contracts were typical, which fits the public documents but is anecdotal.

Where the agreement meets the law

The federal safe harbor and Stark exceptions require a signed writing that covers all the services, a term of at least one year, and compensation set in advance and consistent with fair market value (42 CFR 1001.952(d)(1), 411.357(d)(1)). A side letter or an unwritten expansion of coverage can put the arrangement outside them. Pair every material change with a documented fair market value analysis.

Sources

Where this applies

Back to Insights