Operations

CRNA Supervision Opt-Out States: The 2026 List

By · Published

CRNA Supervision Opt-Out States: The 2026 List

The short answer: as of October 2026, 29 jurisdictions (27 states, the District of Columbia and Guam) have opted out of the Medicare rule that a nurse anesthetist (CRNA) be supervised by a physician, according to the American Association of Nurse Anesthesiology. The most recent is the District of Columbia, in September 2026, after Vermont and Ohio in July. Two, Utah and Wyoming, are partial, limited to critical access and certain rural or small hospitals. Opting out removes a federal condition on the hospital or surgery center; it does not change state scope-of-practice law, a facility’s own bylaws, or how anesthesia is billed.

The federal rule being opted out of

Medicare’s conditions for facilities require a CRNA to work under supervision:

  • Hospitals: supervision by the operating practitioner, or by an anesthesiologist who is immediately available (42 CFR 482.52).
  • Critical access hospitals: supervision by the operating practitioner (42 CFR 485.639).
  • Ambulatory surgery centers: supervision by the operating physician (42 CFR 416.42).
  • Rural emergency hospitals: the same supervision rule and the same opt-out (42 CFR 485.524).

Supervision under these rules does not require an anesthesiologist. In a hospital in a state that has not opted out, the operating practitioner can supervise: usually the surgeon, though the rule’s wording also covers, for example, a dentist or podiatrist operating within their privileges. In a surgery center it must be the operating physician.

Since a 2001 rule change, a state can be exempted. The governor sends CMS a letter attesting that the state’s boards of medicine and nursing were consulted about access to and quality of anesthesia care, that opting out is in the best interests of the state’s residents, and that it is consistent with state law. The opt-out takes effect when the letter is submitted, and a later governor can withdraw it.

States that have opted out

Where the CRNA supervision opt-out applies
29 jurisdictions as of October 2026. Outlined: opted out in 2026 (Ohio, Vermont, District of Columbia).
Opted outPartial (rural and critical access hospitals)Not opted out
AK: opted out 2003AKME: not opted outMEWI: opted out 2005WIVT: opted out 2026VTNH: opted out 2002NHWA: opted out 2003WAID: opted out 2002IDMT: opted out 2004MTND: opted out 2003NDMN: opted out 2002MNIL: not opted outILMI: opted out 2022MINY: not opted outNYMA: opted out 2024MAOR: opted out 2003ORNV: not opted outNVWY: partial opt-out 2023WYSD: opted out 2005SDIA: opted out 2001IAIN: not opted outINOH: opted out 2026OHPA: not opted outPANJ: not opted outNJCT: not opted outCTRI: not opted outRICA: opted out 2009CAUT: partial opt-out 2022UTCO: opted out 2010CONE: opted out 2002NEMO: not opted outMOKY: opted out 2012KYWV: not opted outWVVA: not opted outVAMD: not opted outMDDE: opted out 2023DEAZ: opted out 2020AZNM: opted out 2002NMKS: opted out 2003KSAR: opted out 2022ARTN: not opted outTNNC: not opted outNCSC: not opted outSCDC: opted out 2026DCOK: opted out 2020OKLA: not opted outLAMS: not opted outMSAL: not opted outALGA: not opted outGAHI: not opted outHIGU: opted out 2016GUTX: not opted outTXFL: not opted outFL
Source: American Association of Nurse Anesthesiology, Fact Sheet Concerning State Opt-Outs (September 2026). GU is Guam.
StateOpted outScope
IowaDecember 2001Full
NebraskaFebruary 2002Full
IdahoMarch 2002Full
MinnesotaApril 2002Full
New HampshireJune 2002Full
New MexicoNovember 2002Full
KansasMarch 2003Full
North DakotaOctober 2003Full
WashingtonOctober 2003Full
AlaskaOctober 2003Full
OregonDecember 2003Full
MontanaJanuary 2004Full (withdrawn May 2005, restored June 2005)
South DakotaMarch 2005Full
WisconsinJune 2005Full
CaliforniaJuly 2009Full
ColoradoSeptember 2010Critical access and specified rural hospitals; full from October 2023
KentuckyApril 2012Full
GuamJune 2016Full
ArizonaMarch 2020Full
OklahomaAugust 2020Full
UtahFebruary 2022Partial: critical access and specified rural hospitals
MichiganMay 2022Full
ArkansasMay 2022Full
WyomingMay 2023Partial: critical access hospitals and hospitals with 25 or fewer licensed beds
DelawareJune 2023Full
MassachusettsJune 2024Full
VermontJuly 2026Full
OhioJuly 2026Full
District of ColumbiaSeptember 2026Full (all hospitals)

In alphabetical order, the 27 full opt-outs are Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Delaware, the District of Columbia, Guam, Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, South Dakota, Vermont, Washington and Wisconsin. Utah and Wyoming are partial.

CMS’s own web page on opt-outs is out of date: it still lists 19 states and Guam as of November 2020. The American Society of Anesthesiologists’ own list gives slightly different months for Oklahoma and Massachusetts; the dates here are AANA’s.

What opting out does not change

  • State law. Nurse practice acts and other state rules on CRNA practice still apply, and they vary.
  • A physician director. Hospital anesthesia services must still be under the direction of a qualified doctor of medicine or osteopathy (42 CFR 482.52), so even CRNA-only coverage needs a physician director of anesthesia.
  • The facility’s own rules. A hospital or surgery center in an opt-out state can still require anesthesiologist involvement through its bylaws, credentialing and anesthesia department policies, and some do.
  • Billing. Medicare payment depends on whether a case was medically directed, not on the state. A CRNA working without medical direction bills QZ in any state; medical direction still requires the anesthesiologist to meet all seven conditions. See how the modifiers pay.
  • Anesthesiologist assistants. The opt-out covers CRNAs only. Anesthesiologist assistants still work under an anesthesiologist.

No federal rule change to the supervision requirement was proposed or finalized between 2024 and October 2026. CMS did invite comment twice, in a 2025 request for deregulation ideas and in a February 2026 request for information (CMS-6098-NC), and the nurse anesthetists’ association used both to ask CMS to drop the requirement nationally. The temporary nationwide waiver issued during the COVID-19 emergency ended on May 11, 2023.

What it means for a hospital’s anesthesia model

An opt-out widens the choice of coverage models: CRNA-only coverage at a small or rural site, fewer anesthesiologists covering more rooms, or a mixed model by location. It does not make any of them cheaper by itself. The comparison still turns on local pay, which varies more for CRNAs than for anesthesiologists (CRNA pay by state); on how much of the schedule depends on locums; and on payer policy, since Cigna, Anthem in some states and UnitedHealthcare now pay CRNA claims without medical direction at 85% on their commercial plans (the 85% rule). A model that looks cheaper on staffing can collect less on the same cases. What each care team ratio costs runs the numbers at 2026 pay.

Sources

Back to Insights