Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) and Fair Reimbursement
By Anesthesia Operations Consultants · Published · Updated October 9, 2026
The short answer: Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) is the federal arbitration process created by the No Surprises Act. When an out-of-network provider and a health plan cannot agree on what the plan should pay for a service the Act protects, which includes anesthesia given by an out-of-network group at an in-network hospital or surgery center, either side can send the claim to a certified IDR entity. The entity picks one of the two final offers. It cannot split the difference.
For anesthesia groups, IDR has become the main way to push back on low out-of-network payments, and providers win most of the time: the provider’s offer prevailed in about 85% of payment determinations in the second half of 2025. The rules changed in 2026. The administrative fee fell from $115 to $15 per party, and new batching rules written partly with anesthesia in mind take effect for disputes that begin on or after November 1, 2026. This page sets out how the process works now, what it costs and what has changed.
Federal IDR covers the plans the No Surprises Act governs where no state process applies: a fully insured plan in a state with its own surprise-billing law uses the state’s process, and Medicare and Medicaid patients are outside it.
What the latest data shows
CMS publishes IDR results twice a year. The most recent full report, released in July 2026, covers July to December 2025.
- Volume keeps rising. 2,559,375 disputes were started in 2025, up from 1,463,872 in 2024 and 679,156 in 2023. A further 2,145,850 were started between January and July 2026.
- Providers usually win. In July–December 2025 the initiating party, almost always the provider, won about 85% of the 1,145,039 payment determinations, down slightly from 88% in the first half of the year.
- Awards sit well above the QPA. The winning offer was above the plan’s qualifying payment amount (QPA), its median in-network rate, in about 87% of determinations.
- Eligibility fights are common. Plans argued that 42% of disputes were ineligible; IDR entities found 19% of all disputes ineligible.
Anesthesia specifically
About 58,000 payment determinations a quarter involved anesthesia codes (CPT 00100–01999) in the second half of 2025, roughly one in ten of all determinations outside air ambulance. The median winning offer in anesthesia disputes has risen sharply against the QPA, with dips along the way:
| Quarter | Median winning offer, anesthesia, as % of QPA |
|---|---|
| Q1 2023 | 173% |
| Q4 2023 | 219% |
| Q1 2024 | 207% |
| Q4 2024 | 331% |
| Q1 2025 | 309% |
| Q2 2025 | 312% |
| Q3 2025 | 326% |
| Q4 2025 | 361% |
What the case-level data shows
CMS’s summary tables do not report a win rate for anesthesia alone, but it also publishes the individual dispute records behind them. We analyzed the 2025 files for anesthesia codes (CPT 00100–01999): 357,632 disputed anesthesia line items reached a payment determination in 2025, in about 241,000 disputes, roughly 6% of all line items decided that year. The median winning offers we calculate match the quarterly figures CMS publishes in the table above.
- Providers win about four times in five, and slightly less each quarter. The provider’s offer was chosen on 81.9% of anesthesia line items in 2025, down from 85.0% in January–March to 79.5% in October–December, and below the roughly 85% rate across all services in the second half of the year.
- The offers are far apart. In October–December 2025 the median plan offer was 1.2 times the QPA and the median provider offer 5.2 times; the median winning offer was 3.6 times.
- Most involve employer plans. About 79% of the anesthesia line items involved self-insured employer plans, which state surprise-billing laws generally do not reach.
- Three states dominate. Florida, Texas and Arizona accounted for 60% of anesthesia line items.
- Endoscopy leads. Anesthesia for GI endoscopy (codes 00731, 00811, 00812 and 00813) made up 30% of the line items; screening colonoscopy alone (00812) was 14%.
- Fees. The median certified IDR entity fee in these disputes was about $600.
What IDR costs
| Fee | Amount | Applies |
|---|---|---|
| Administrative fee, per party per dispute | $15 | Disputes started on or after June 11, 2026 |
| Administrative fee, per party per dispute | $115 | January 22, 2024 to June 10, 2026 |
| IDR entity fee, single determination | $200–$840 | Since January 2024, unchanged in 2026 |
| IDR entity fee, batched determination (2–25 line items) | $268–$1,173 | Plus $75–$250 for each further 25 line items |
Each IDR entity sets its own fee within those ranges. Both sides pay the entity’s fee up front and the winner’s is refunded, so in effect the losing party pays. If the parties settle after the entity has found the dispute eligible, the fee is split; settle before that and each side gets its fee back. The administrative fee is paid by both sides regardless of the outcome. The lower administrative fee helps, but it does not make a small claim cheap to dispute: both sides still prepay the entity’s fee, typically about $425–$800 today, and the losing side forfeits it.
The timeline
| Step | Deadline |
|---|---|
| Start open negotiation with the plan | Within 30 business days of the initial payment or denial |
| Open negotiation | 30 business days |
| Start IDR if negotiation fails | Within 4 business days after negotiation ends |
| Submit final offers | 10 business days after the IDR entity is selected |
| Decision | 30 business days after the entity is selected |
| Plan pays the award | Within 30 calendar days of the decision |
| Cooling-off before the same parties dispute the same service again | 90 calendar days (30 business days for batched disputes whose negotiation starts on or after November 1, 2026) |
The windows are short and they are enforced. Claims that miss them are lost to the process, which is why groups that use IDR well track every out-of-network payment from the day it arrives.
What changed in 2026
The federal IDR operations rule, proposed in November 2023, was finalized and published on June 4, 2026, and took effect on August 3, 2026. The parts that matter most for anesthesia:
- The $15 administrative fee, from June 11, 2026.
- Batching built for anesthesia. For disputes whose open negotiation starts on or after November 1, 2026, anesthesia services can be batched within the same anesthesia code range (CMS’s October 2026 guidance lists 19, grouped by body region), and the add-on codes 99100, 99116, 99135 and 99140 can travel with the anesthesia code they modify. Batches are also capped for the first time, at 50 line items. Batching by anesthesia conversion factor was considered and rejected.
- More information from plans. Plans must give more detail, including QPA information, with initial payments and denials from August 3, 2026, and must use standard remittance codes for services from January 1, 2027.
- A new portal. CMS opened sign-up for the IDR Gateway on September 15, 2026, and the old web forms stop working outside it after January 15, 2027. Starting open negotiation through the portal will become the required route 90 days after CMS announces that feature; CMS expects to begin adding Gateway features in spring 2027, and open negotiation is not first in line.
- Unpaid fees. A party that has not paid its fees has its offer treated as not received (this writes existing guidance into the regulation).
Separately, in August 2026 the full Fifth Circuit struck down two of the rules plans used to calculate the QPA: counting “ghost rates” for services a contracted provider never performs, and leaving out bonus and incentive payments. Plans are expected to recalculate, which should raise QPAs, the benchmark most IDR offers are measured against.
Getting paid after you win
The law gives plans 30 calendar days to pay an award, and the 2026 rule adds no new penalty for paying late. The agencies say they will enforce the deadline through existing processes, and providers can report non-payment to the No Surprises Help Desk. A clinician survey cited in an April 2026 letter co-signed by the American Society of Anesthesiologists reported that 11% of 2024 awards went unpaid, and half of those paid arrived late. Insurers’ own survey says plans paid nearly three out of four awards within 30 days.
Going to court is not a reliable fallback. Two federal appeals courts have now held that the No Surprises Act gives providers no private right to sue to enforce an IDR award: the Fifth Circuit, whose ruling the Supreme Court declined to review in January 2026 (Guardian Flight v. HCSC), binding in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi; and the Second Circuit in September 2026 (East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna), binding in New York, Connecticut and Vermont. Claims under other laws, such as ERISA, were dismissed for how they were pleaded, not ruled out.
Congress is considering a fix. The No Surprises Act Enforcement Act (H.R. 4710 in the House, S. 2420 in the Senate), introduced in July 2025, would make a plan that pays an award late or not at all owe three times the difference between its initial payment and the award, plus interest. As of October 2026 both bills are in committee. An earlier version, H.R. 9572, died at the end of the last Congress.
Why it matters to the hospital paying the subsidy
Many anesthesia groups collect less than their coverage costs, and the hospital’s subsidy covers the gap. Out-of-network underpayment is part of that gap. Only a small share of eligible claims reach IDR at all: insurers’ own survey of 2024 claims put it at about 6% of qualifying claims, with most of the rest accepted at the initial payment or settled. A group that disputes systematically and wins at current rates collects more from plans and needs less from the hospital.
“It’s helping anesthesia providers push back against unsustainable payer behavior and, importantly, reduce—or in some cases, completely eliminate—subsidy requirements for their facility clients,” said Stacy Dawson, Director of Business Development at Phoenix-based BillWell, when this article was first published in 2025.
For a hospital, the practical question at renewal is whether the group is using the process. A subsidy request from a group that leaves IDR-eligible claims unfiled is asking the hospital to cover payments the group could recover from plans.
Sources
- Federal Register, Federal Independent Dispute Resolution Operations, final rules (June 4, 2026), and the CMS fact sheet.
- CMS, Federal IDR supplemental background, Q3–Q4 2025, and the quarterly supplemental tables.
- CMS, Federal IDR public use files, January–December 2025 (dispute line-item data), analyzed by AOC for anesthesia codes 00100–01999.
- CMS, IDR reports and bi-monthly updates, and the list of certified IDR entities and their fees.
- Congress.gov, H.R. 4710, No Surprises Act Enforcement Act.
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna, No. 25-2204 (September 17, 2026).
- Supreme Court docket No. 25-441, Guardian Flight v. HCSC.
Contributor to the original 2025 edition: Stacy Dawson, Director, Business Development, BillWell · 972-415-2556 · sdawson@billwell.net